When it is enough to update, secure and speed up a site, and when every further patch is wasted money. Including when the answer is: don’t rebuild.
Before you order a rebuild
I build WordPress sites myself, and still I don’t push people to rebuild. Plenty of old WordPress sites can be brought to a good state for a fraction of the price of a new one. The question is whether yours is one of them.
When patching is enough
- The site looks good and still says what it should say. The problem is technical, not about image.
- There are a few plugins, not several dozen, and all of them are still being developed.
- The theme is popular and gets updates.
- The site hasn’t been taken over repeatedly, and if it was once, it is known how, and the hole has been closed.
- After updating and turning on caching it loads in a reasonable time.
What proper patching includes
- A full backup before anything is touched.
- Updating WordPress, the theme, the plugins and the PHP version on the server.
- Removing unused plugins, themes and accounts.
- Strong passwords, two-step login for administrators and a limit on login attempts.
- Speeding it up: caching, compression and smaller images.
- Automatic backups stored outside the server and a plan for future updates.
When patching stops making sense
- A key plugin or the theme hasn’t been developed for years and has no successor.
- The site sits on a heavy visual builder, and every change to the look breaks the layout on a phone.
- There are several dozen plugins and nobody knows any more which one does what.
- The site has been taken over several times and the same problem returns every time.
- The look and content need changing anyway. Then patching the old foundation means paying twice.
How to decide
Ask for a review before you order anything else. A good review ends with a list: what is out of date, what threatens security and how long it would take to put right.
Compare that amount, together with the yearly cost of maintenance, to the cost of a new site over three years. If patching comes out much cheaper, patch. If it is about the same, a rebuild usually wins, because you end up with a site that is easier to maintain.
Key takeaway
Patch when the problem is technical and the foundation is still alive. Rebuild when the theme and plugins are abandoned, the problems come back after every break-in, or the look needs changing anyway.